image
The Abraham Connection Questions & Answers :: View topic - Can a Prophet Sin?
The Abraham Connection Questions & Answers Forum Index

 
Register   FAQ   Search  Log in

Can a Prophet Sin?

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    The Abraham Connection Questions & Answers Forum Index -> Sin in the Quran
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
abdul
Site Admin


Joined: 21 Jul 2006
Posts: 27

Post Post subject: Can a Prophet Sin? Reply with quote

A number of Muslim scholars believe that Prophets do not sin. Others accept it based on the Quran that they do, but they are "minor" sins only. These in general are treated as mistakes. Those who do not beleive that Mohammad sinned, is not based on the teachings of the Quran, but based on two fundamental reasons outside of the Quran. One is that Jesus is the only one in the Quran is said to be "blameless". This results in embrassement for some Muslims, as Mohammad is asked to ask for forgiveness. Two, if Mohammad or any of the Prophets were sinners, than how can we have a "pure" revelation from God. Coming through "impure" and "sinful" Prophets would result in these being corrupted. Those who accept that Prophets commit minor sin, do so, but not in the matter of receiving relevation.

Sunni Muslim translators of the Quran use differeing approaches to the issue of Sin of the Prophets. Notice how Shakir uses the word "fault" and not "sin". In my opinion, of the three translators that are commonly used by Sunni Muslim - Yusuf Ali, Shakir and Pickthal, Pickthal is generally more "literal", while Shakir is the one who is "interpretive" and Yusuf Ali is in the middle.

Note how this ayat is tranlated. Yusuf Ali uses the word "sin" while Shakir use "fault".
    (Their plight will be) no better than that of the people of Pharaoh, and their predecessors: They denied our Signs, and God called them to account for their sins. For God is strict in punishment. Yusuf Ali, Quran 3:11

    Like the striving of the people of Firon and those before them; they rejected Our communications, so Allah destroyed them on account of their faults; and Allah is severe in requiting (evil). Shakir, Quran 3:11

Now when we come to the Sins of Mohammad, even Yusuf Ali is "interpretive". He now translates the same arabic word "dhanb" above as "sin", but below as "faults" while Pickthal is consistent in treating it as "sin".

    That God may forgive thee thy faults of the past and those to follow; fulfil His favour to thee; and guide thee on the Straight Way; Yusuf Al, Quran 48:2

    That Allah may forgive thee of thy sin that which is past and that which is to come, and may perfect His favour unto thee, and may guide thee on a right path, Pickthall, Quran 48:2

Check out the sin of other prophets **

of Abraham, al-Anbiya' 21:51; ash-Shu`ara' 26:82

of Adam, al-A`raf 7:20-23

of David, Sad 38:25

of Moses, al-Qasas 28:15-16

is forgiven, al-Qasas 28:16
* This Qur'anic verse is clear that God forgave Moses for his wrong. What is there to forgive if there is no wrong?

of Muhammad, al-Ahzab 33:37; Muhammad 47:19;

of Noah, Hud 11:47


Questions to consider:
1. Why do translators inconsistently use the word "sin" for dhanb?

2. Why is it that Pharoah was punished for "dhanb", but Prophets are not?

3. If there was no "sin", why is Mohammad and Moses required to ask for forgiveness?

** The details of these ayah and its treatment is from Answering-Islam website under the Islamic Index on Sin.
Sat Aug 19, 2006 6:30 pm
Back to top
abdul View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    The Abraham Connection Questions & Answers Forum Index -> Sin in the Quran All times are GMT - 4 Hours
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


MSSimplicity Theme © Matt Sims 2004

Original Simplicity theme created for vB by Dominic Jacob, ported to phpBB with permission
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
image
image
image